The Roger Smith ★★★

€124.86
avg/night
Rate and special offer based on
Check-in 8 May 2016 Check-out 9 May 2016

Old old old...

Would not recommend Sat 18 Oct 2014
Good location, large rooms but ... old old old interior and ac did not work properly!! Specially depressing lobby...

| Miami Business

2 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 1 /5
  • Cleanliness: 3 /5
  • Hotel staff: 2 /5
  • Comfort: 2 /5
  • Location: 4 /5
  • Value: 2 /5

Old school hotel at value

Would recommend Sat 18 Oct 2014
Older hotel but good value especially during high traffic weeks in NYC when newer hotels are charging double their normal rate.

Time saver

If you are coming in from out of town, cabs are tempting but subway will always be faster

| California Business

4 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 3 /5
  • Cleanliness: 4 /5
  • Hotel staff: 5 /5
  • Comfort: 4 /5
  • Location: 4 /5
  • Value: 4 /5

good choice

Would recommend Mon 28 Jul 2014
Nice location, efficient staff. Nice room, spacious for NYC, though it was hard to find electrical outlets. Rooftop bar is pleasant for a drink & conversation.

Shopping hint

Grand Central Market - nice variety of food & other stuff, easy walk from the Roger Smith.

| PA Couples

4 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 4 /5
  • Cleanliness: 5 /5
  • Hotel staff: 4 /5
  • Comfort: 4 /5
  • Location: 4 /5
  • Value: 4 /5

family get away visiting son

Would recommend Mon 21 Jul 2014
Family of four visiting son/brother on his summer internship. Hotel Jr. Suite was a cute, homey room with a queen bed and queen size pull out coach. Felt like we were vacationing at grandmas. Great location, accommodating staff, quiet, yummy yogurt and granola in the morning. Easy access unloading and hotel staff valeted car at a nearby garage at $40.00/night. Only complaint was the mattress was a bit lumpy and property felt a bit dated.

| PA Family

3 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 4 /5
  • Cleanliness: 3 /5
  • Hotel staff: 4 /5
  • Comfort: 3 /5
  • Location: 5 /5
  • Value: 4 /5

Lovely boutique style hotel

Would recommend Mon 30 Jun 2014
The room was very comfortable and clean, the staff attentive and friendly. Although I am a West Side type, the location was very convenient, the vibe cozy and relaxed. High ceilings made the inevitably small room feel spacious.

| West Hartford, CT Family

5 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 4 /5
  • Cleanliness: 5 /5
  • Hotel staff: 5 /5
  • Comfort: 5 /5
  • Location: 4 /5
  • Value: 4 /5

Excellent Location and Big rooms

Would recommend Mon 30 Jun 2014
Excellent location and comfortable big rooms.The suite was as big as a 1BR apartment.

| Boston, Ma Family

4 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 3 /5
  • Cleanliness: 5 /5
  • Hotel staff: 4 /5
  • Comfort: 5 /5
  • Location: 5 /5
  • Value: 4 /5

OK hotel in good location

Would recommend Fri 27 Jun 2014
i didnt want to spend $400+ on a one night stay but wanted a nice comfortable bed and a good shower. The lobby is pretty old and tatty and the reception staff were pretty good, checking me in quickly. The bellman was not around very much so took my own bags which was not a problem. The room was quite old looking and the a/c was 1970's i think but it still worked so i cant complain too much but be aware of it. the bed was very comfortable though and sheets were all clean and white and the shower looked amazing. The water flow was pretty poor though but amenities were good and plenty of nice clean towels All in all a decent value hotel but it needs a makeover !!

| London UK Business

3 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 3 /5
  • Cleanliness: 4 /5
  • Hotel staff: 3 /5
  • Comfort: 3 /5
  • Location: 4 /5
  • Value: 3 /5

Graduation for our daughter

Would recommend Mon 2 Jun 2014
We were impressed with the room, very large for New York!! Loved the roof top bar. Staff was very courteous.

| San Diego, CA Family

4 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 4 /5
  • Cleanliness: 4 /5
  • Hotel staff: 4 /5
  • Comfort: 4 /5
  • Location: 4 /5
  • Value: 3 /5

Free yogurt! Awesome

Would recommend Mon 30 Sep 2013
Spacious room. Great location. Free yogurt and granola, need I say more?

| Trenton, NJ Couples

4 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 4 /5
  • Cleanliness: 4 /5
  • Hotel staff: 4 /5
  • Comfort: 3 /5
  • Location: 5 /5
  • Value: 4 /5

visiting NYC

Would not recommend Tue 25 Jun 2013
ok, clean, friendly, great location, nice roof top bar

| syracuse Couples

3 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 3 /5
  • Cleanliness: 5 /5
  • Hotel staff: 5 /5
  • Comfort: 5 /5
  • Location: 4 /5
  • Value: 2 /5