Best 4 Star Hotels in Key West Historic District

"The Best Hotel in Key West 10 stars!!!!"

"My husband and I woke up with bed bug bites and the air conditioner was not functioning properly the last night of our visit. This was not the room that was shown on your website - we did not have a partial island view. The hallway was open to the beach all day and all night. We were surprised when we arrived that we would have to pay a $65 charge per day for each of us. That was not listed in the description on your website. We would never stay at this hotel again."

"Booked here to spoil my girlfriend on her birthday and they were accommodating. Gave me a lovely room with a view right over the harbor. The room was clean and comfy. The available water bottles in the room and near the elevator were very nice for the resort fee. But the $40 valet fee I wasn't impressed with and here's why. I am a valet bellman myself, so I was excited to be on the other side of the experience. But when I pulled in, the valets didn't greet my car, they stood at their podium and talked and I was the only car there. I had to get out and walk up to them, and interrupt them. It didn't bother too much at the moment as of course I was in a great mood being on vacation and quickly told them I do what they do and am happy to be in Florida. They were nice, and I still tipped them well on all bell runs and car retrievals. But they should be approaching the car, greeting me and welcoming me first, especially at the price of valet and the hefty price of the rooms. Overall, it was great stay, just very expensive so you expect a level of customer service that matches."